Letter to the Editor: Special Interest Group Behind School Board's Calendar Vote
Submit letters to the editor to gaetana.pipia@patch.com
Now in my fourth decade on the planet, I thought I possessed a modestly experienced view of the world. I hardly expected to be proved foolishly naive at this point. How wrong I was.
I understood quite well that politicians were all influenced by special interests to some degree or another. However, when it came to school boards, I believed those who ran and served were somehow different. I naively thought school board members rose above the fray to serve the best interest of the students and basically went about the business of building schools and funding classrooms. I thought they were public servants in the broader sense, rather than, well, politicians.
The Cobb County Board of Education recently proved me wrong with the Feb. 17 vote to change the school calendar. On the surface, it would seem nothing more than three newly sworn-in board members honoring positions from their campaigns stating a preference for a later start date in August.
However, I voted for one of these candidates, Kathleen Angelucci, and found myself shocked by how abrupt the change came. And I'm hardly alone. The community has been outspoken on the decision, SACS has inquired about the change, and the Cobb County grand jury weighed in this month. In addition to being shocked by the hasty change, I have also been dissatisfied with all the reasons board members have given for the change and began doing a little research of my own.
It's this research that has opened my eyes to how wildly naive my views on school board members have been. I write this as a warning to others. Beware.
Beginning sometime in the 1990s, a group of citizens began advocating for a shorter school year and a 12-week-or-longer summer in the state of Texas. This group evolved into Texans for a Traditional School Year, then into a national group called the Coalition for a Traditional School Year. The former group was successful in getting a state law passed in Texas that strips control from local school boards and mandates a statewide public school start date of the fourth Monday in August or later. Both groups are led by Texan Tina Bruno.
Fast-forward to the new millennium and a similar group forms in Georgia. This group eventually incorporates as Georgians Need Summers. According to its own website, www.georgiansneedsummers.com, the group is a “nonprofit grassroots organization" that basically advocates for a shorter school year and a longer summer. And here is where it gets interesting for Georgians.
(1) In papers filed with the Georgia secretary of state, Georgians Need Summers claims to be a nonprofit, specifically a 501(c)(4). However, the IRS has no record of this organization being an exempt nonprofit, and there are no publicly available tax returns (a legal requirement for nonprofits) available through http://www.guidestar.com (even the IRS routinely directs callers to GuideStar for nonprofit tax returns).
(2) In those same papers, Georgians Need Summers states it is organized for "the promotion of the social welfare of the people of the State of Georgia, including promoting and lobbying for a SHORTER school year for the students of the State of Georgia."
(3) The papers go on to state that "no substantial part of the activities of the corporation shall be the carrying on of political activities, and the corporation shall not participate in, or intervene in (including the publishing or distribution of statements) any political campaign on behalf of any candidate for public office."
Why is all this relevant? Because I, and many of my fellow citizens in Cobb, have been busy going about our lives and raising our families, and we unfortunately missed the following:
(1) Georgians Need Summers never amended its documents with the secretary of state and still claims to be "a grassroots nonprofit" on the website. They are listed as a “Profit Corporation–Domestic.”
(2) Georgians Need Summers was administratively dissolved by the secretary of state on May 16, 2008, and its certificate of corporation was revoked.
(3) Vivian Jackson, co-founder of Georgians Need Summers, and Kathleen Angelucci (present school board member) actively campaigned for the election of school board member Dr. John Abraham in 2006.
(4) Lane Holt, co-founder of Georgians Need Summers, served as campaign manager of the Committee to Elect Scott Sweeney in 2010. Sweeney won a school board seat and was sworn in on Jan. 6. As early as Jan. 9, he began to request that the school calendar be placed on the board's agenda.
I also found that Lane Holt was quoted in an article for the Atlanta Business Chronicle on Aug. 4, 2008, as saying, “Many school-board candidates are endorsing moving back the school calendar, and if one district takes that step, it will generate enough momentum for others to follow.” You’ll note Holt’s comments came after the secretary of state administratively dissolved Georgians Need Summers.
(5) Jackson and Holt have testified before the Georgia General Assembly in support of a statewide uniform start date for public schools. The most recent bill considered was H.B. 1097, which would have required all Georgia public schools to begin no earlier than the third full week in August.
(6) Scotti Madison, listed as the executive director of Georgians Need Summers, made a campaign contribution to Angelucci's election committee in 2010. Angelucci won a school board seat and was sworn in Jan. 6.
(7) After the November 2009 vote to adopt the balanced calendar for three years in Cobb schools, three parents in opposition to the balanced calendar were interviewed: Madison, Sweeney and Angelucci. Madison was identified as a founder of Georgians Need Summers in the interview.
(8) Catherine Busse served as the Campaign chairwoman for Angelucci's 2010 election committee and as the campaign support staff for Sweeney. While Busse's direct affiliation with Georgians Need Summers is unclear, she is known to be affiliated with Lane Holt and perhaps other leadership of Georgians Need Summers. She has also been a registered lobbyist with the state of Georgia.
(9) Georgians Need Summers has continued to publish information since its corporate dissolution. Per Georgia law, an administratively dissolved corporation may carry out only the business necessary to close the operation. Since the dissolution date, there have been no fewer than 15 articles and/or press statements published and credited to the co-founders of Georgians Need Summers. In March 2010, Lane Holt published a letter in support of H.B. 1097 and may have distributed this letter through the Georgians Need Summers network–clearly ongoing business.
(10) Georgians Need Summers has maintained its website, which is paid through Sept. 8. Interestingly, Tina Bruno is listed as the website's owner and/or administrator (remember, Bruno began organizing these groups in Texas). Bruno also happens to be the owner and/or administrator for www.SaveTennesseeSummers.org, www.SaveAlabamaSummers.org, www.SaveFloridaSummers.org, www.Save PennsylvaniaSummers.org and www.SaveArkansasSummers.org.
Bruno is also likely the ultimate owner of the websites for Texans for a Traditional School Year and the Coalition for a Traditional School Year, the organizations she launched. Plus, the groups for North Carolina and South Carolina are affiliated with the national coalition and state groups as well. The Wall Street Journal said: “One group, Texans for a Traditional School Year, says it has received funding from a powerful ally: the tourism industry. So far this year the group has received nearly $25,000, much of it from businesses ranging from hotels and restaurants to the ‘T-shirt people.’ ”
I'll admit, it truly never occurred to me that a special interest group was orchestrating elections for the Cobb County Board of Education on a countywide basis. My Post 4 school board candidate, Kathleen Angelucci, was the only name listed on the ballot in November. Although I was aware she didn’t support the balanced calendar, nowhere did I hear or see campaign statements made that she would “repeal or revert” to another calendar as her first official board business, changing a calendar that was already voted on and published for three years. I was further caught blindsided when I learned that the same special interest group had been working for years to strip control from local school boards across Georgia.
I write this as a warning to others. Do not be as naive as I have been. Citizens of Cherokee, Rockdale, Henry, Paulding and Douglas counties, take heed. You and the other 29 metro Atlanta counties where public schools begin in early August are at risk. School districts that choose modified calendars are in danger of losing their say to special interests like Georgians Need Summers and the tourism industry. My school board in Cobb County is now entrenched with this special interest group. Watch your elections carefully, or you may find yourself looking in the mirror wondering how you could have been so naive too.
Tricia Knor
Acworth-area parent, Kell High School district
Vanessa
9:51 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Interesting
Patricia
8:16 am on Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Well . . . this reads like 6 degrees of separation. Running for any publicly elected office takes money and volunteers. It does not matter if you run with a (D) by your name or an (R) by your name. Regarding Angelucci, there was no opponent in the general election, but there was in the primary and he was well-funded and well-known. It takes about 5-10 minutes/day in the fall to be an educated voter. No elected official is going to vote exactly as you (individually) would vote every time - this is representative government. It's because of these different votes that other people decide to run for office - this is representative government. I consider that if the elected person votes how I would about 90% of the time, then that's good; otherwise, I'd have to run for public office and I have no desire to give up my freedom or my privacy, which the elected officials willingly give up to serve us. These newest board members were always clear before elections about how they would vote on a calendar issue.
Patricia
8:20 am on Thursday, May 19, 2011
How about I'm a ~disillusioned devil's advocate~?
I do believe the calendar survey results were 'hedged.'
Her opponent's name was . . . Bill Borden, the Iditerod guy.
Angelucci has been vocal and well-known in the area for years. Robb, run for office if you can do better, but remember that some disgruntled person will be crawling up your backside every time you vote, no matter how you vote.
I will say that I am opposed to school starting in August, and I teach. It is TOO HOT in Georgia in early August to have children on the non-air conditioned buses, playing outside to get the wiggles out, with teachers praying every day that the school air conditioners will keep working. I also had an awful time this winter getting students into any routine after snow days followed by too many breaks.
I know several precious families who have planned September vacations. I say let them do what they've planned. They are the parents; teachers are not gods. Willing teachers can handle the adjustment and prioritize assignments when they return. Other students may get some enrichment or personalized help that week.
Though I personally hate August school, if we really want a 'balanced' calendar, then let's go to school most of the summer perhaps with only July off. Two early weeks in August does not make a 'balanced' calendar. In return, give us the whole month of December off -- we all know how busy that time of year is.
Robb
5:32 pm on Wednesday, May 18, 2011
It's about time this came out.
I'm literally fascinated at the number of under informed people who believe there is nothing wrong with our school baord and they are just doing their elected jobs. If that's the case, sign me up for the next election, I've got a boat load of things I'd like to force down people's throat's, after all, it's for their own good, right?
Vanessa
9:11 am on Thursday, May 19, 2011
Neighbor- I am very concern you are a teacher, your attitude is not what I would expect from someone who enjoys teaching and loves children.
The school board has not made (to my knowledge) accommodations for parents who have paid and planned a vacation in Sept or Feb. Are you suggesting that we break the law and pull our children out of school?
As far it being too hot, I agree that Cobb should have planned better and been prepared with air-condition buses. But, as a parent of a child with asthma, I have to pick him up or take him from school in April , May, Sept, Oct because of the heat on the bus. We live in Georgia we could have 90 weather in April. May, June, July, August, September, October and November too. We cannot take all those months off.
I am glad you knew who Angelucci was before she ran for the board, as well known as you thought she was I never heard about her. When she ran, I went to a meeting to find out more about her, she told me she was just a concern PTA parent and was not for the balanced calendar -BUT there were bigger problem she was concern with- She changed her mind pretty quickly on that.
As for having the month off in December-Please tell me you are not serious? You do not like the balance calendar because it hard for students to get back into the routine- but you are ok with having the month of December off- It will be like the beginning of school all over again! That makes no sense to me.
Patricia
7:54 am on Friday, May 20, 2011
My first posted opinion related to the school board, elections & the calendar.
Vanessa, your first statement borders on personal attack. I truly care for my students and show them respect and compassion. I am available before and after school and make time to help them, even with brainstorming projects for classes I don't teach. They know this and for the most part are very respectful and kind toward me.
Read the attendance law. At worst - may lose driver's license and possibly visit from social worker, but that is rare if the student is generally a good student with involved parents.
I am in my fifth decade of life. I taught fresh out of college as a young idealist. I worked corporate. I returned to teaching. I battled and survived cancer. I returned to teaching. I do not say this for your sympathy. I bring this up because of my initially posted opinion regarding those with planned vacations - teachers come and go, teachers can be replaced or transferred or promoted; parents, brothers, sisters are not replaceable. I treat the parents of my students with utmost respect and I have many notes and cards stating so. If a parent tells me ahead of time they have family plans, then I do everything I can to cooperate with priority assignments vs busy work.
Vanessa
9:12 am on Thursday, May 19, 2011
My concern is not the calendar, my concern is the lack of respect the current board has shown Cobb County parent AND teachers. I do hope the training they are receiving, will help them understand the issues they have caused.
Misty
9:26 am on Thursday, May 19, 2011
It only takes a few minutes of your life to become an informed voter, but you will live will the consequences of blind voting for years.
Vanessa
9:35 am on Thursday, May 19, 2011
Misty-I have never voted blindly- I expect to be lied to by politicians, I guess I expected more from School Board Members, I am now fully aware that they are regular politicians who do not care about children and from now on I will treat them and think of them as politicians. My questions is who is looking out for our children education?
Terra
7:49 pm on Thursday, May 19, 2011
I am currently a teacher in Cobb County, and I fully supported the balanced calender. The frequent breaks during this past year were so beneficial for students and their families and a wonderful opportunity or teachers to refuel their excitement for teaching. I just think a 11 or 12 week summer break for students is too long. Most students take a week or two week trip at best, and then sit in the house playing video games and watching TV 24/7. Even the local swimming pools become sparsely visited in August even though it is the hottest month of the year. Young people today do not work outside the home, or on a farm, so I see no reason to delay school until mid or late August. As for the heat, it can be hot during many months in GA, and the air conditioning runs most months of the school year anyway. It is the student who loses valuable instructional segments, with off-season travel opportunities who really loses out with the traditional calendar. I hope this issue has propelled many new school board candidates for our next election cycle.
Vanessa
9:42 am on Friday, May 20, 2011
Thank-you for a teacher's point of view